Live Help
Live Help

Homebuilder has registered a complaint toward Water District alleging water supplied by the district causes leaks within water lines.

Santa Ana, CA: Two additional home builders have lodged grievances with Orange County Superior Court alleging the water made available from the South County water districts has been corroding plumbing, which causes water leaks which require hundreds of thousands of dollars in copper repiping repair and installs.

Shapell Industries filed their grievance November 2, alleging the water transferred by Moulton Niguel Water District for Shapell residences located in multiple Laguna Niguel subdivisions; San Joaquin Hills in addition to Hillcrest were treated with chloramine, a chemical disinfectant of which Shapell suggested is known to cause pinhole leaks in the pipes of homeowners throughout the area.

The grievance states Shapell “will be forced to restore and remove and redo plumbing in over 500 residences” in those locations. The protest doesn’t seem to designate the actual number of houses that actually have water leaks. The construtor is seeking out around $7 million in damages, stating product liability, recklessness, private nuisance and infraction of service contract.

MNWD provides service to 57,000 houses and businesses in Laguna Niguel, Aliso Viejo, Laguna Hills and parts of Mission Viejo and San Juan Capistrano.

“The only consumers filing a complaint associated with these kinds of pipe leaks are living in properties manufactured by Shapell in these two locales,” MNWD general manager Bob Gumerman said with a statement. “If the water was to blame, the condition would certainly be popular.”

Gumerman highlighted the district’s water hits or surpasses federal and state water-quality standards and is suitable for consuming or other usages. He explained Shapell hasn’t released information about how MNWD’s water supply has led to pinhole water leaks in people’s homes. Several voice messages to the legal professionals which represent Shapell weren’t returned.

Gumerman stated Moulton Niguel obtains its water supply through the Metropolitan Water District of Southern California, who imports it by way of the Colorado River as well as the State Water Project, a program of storage areas, tanks and lakes. Based on its internet site, MWD may make use of chloramine, a blend of chlorine and ammonia, in the water treatment operation to remove bacteria in the water.

MWD also offers water for the Santa Margarita Water District, which services the rest of Mission Viejo and in addition Rancho Santa Margarita, Coto de Caza, Ladera Ranch along with the Talega local community in San Clemente. MWD and SMWD were branded as defendants in a grievance recorded Feb. 6 by Lennar Homes related to pin hole water leaks in aged pipes inside the Verano area of Talega.

Lennar’s briefing claims pipe leaks in galvanized piping in 60 Verano homes “are the principal and/or legitimate result of harsh, extreme andinaccurately treated water” provided by the districts. Lennar is looking for the districts to be held answerable for the water leaks and for any expenses, harms or settlements suffered by Lennar brought on by the water leaks.

Newmeyer & Dillion legal representative Carol Zaist, which will be representing Lennar, said the builder is unable to talk about unresolved legal matters.

Newmeyer & Dillion also represents home developer Standard Pacific, which lodged a complaint brought to the district in December located 75 residences in Ladera Ranch and Talega where home buyers have made note of pinhole leaks in water pipes and associated property damage. The declaration was earlier repudiated by SMWD officials, but recent research may overturn this primary consideration.

SMWD speaker Michele Miller thought the district does not modify or change the water which is available from MWD, also mentioning SMWD water satisfies or is more than national water quality guidelines. Concerning the negative effects of water treatments, “the district believes there is no additional info to indicate that the region’s water supply is causing a corrosive effect on galvanized piping.”

Marc Edwards is known as a Virginia Tech city and environmental engineering educator as well as a nationwide identified specialist on pipe corrosion. An integral part of his work is to go through the causes of pipe deficiencies and how to put an end to them. He said that a great number of law suits are emerging in California and that he can possibly expect to become retained as the expert witness.

“We’ve completed more than likely over a million dollars of scientific tests in the past seven years,” Edwards explained. “Today we have observed that water chemistry and harsh water are key contributing factors of pinhole leaks.

“We realize that other causes are often times involved, including severe velocity in plumbing and mediocre installation practices, consequently every condition normally takes truly intensive forensic evaluation to try to assess the possible underlying cause and treatment options,” he added.

Edwards said similar standards carried out to render drinking water safer could possibly be contributing to pinhole water leaks. Even though disinfectants are necessary, far too much in most waters may just be corrosive. He said preliminary research on chloramine shows it by itself doesn’t always facilitate corrosion in water pipes, nevertheless “it is realistic, even expected, that chloramine plus other elements in the water are often remarkably corrosive.”

Even though they probably have effective intentions, corrections in order to reach regulations may just be developing unintended repercussions, Edwards stated.

“There is much that we acknowledge,” he stated. “We have all unambiguously recognized that this type of water is often a cause; not the particular sole cause, but a cause. There is certainly quite a bit many of us still can never predict.”